Oceans of Wisdom

not immediately related to the topic

also related / unrelated

thanks brosef. it is still plenty affordable for top collectors

almost done!

could be worse, you could be me, a moron, who forgot to subscribe family for SZN10 and have been grinding (well @[DarrenSRS] to be fair) to get it back

what is the current bid/ask cost of a full set

it is not too late for them

the complete system of: - TDH accrual - Edition size - AL is very important to the protocol so the way I think about it something like 'some day vitalik will read the algorithm" and I do not want him to say "my god these guys are morons, they have spent 4 years working on this and here are 3 obvious holes"

so let's harden it as much as possible

and it will have to survive by itself

into the wild

at some point we will let go of the baby

let's push our thinking to the maximum

this is what they are saying in effect

yeah but a full set collector has more pressure to fill each spot

it is best to start your full set journey way before SZN40 or to be very rich!

we do it all in public here!

the issue is that people are using it tactically for the higher value cards right?

if all high TDH people said "we want to buy 3 of every card then editions would be 600 or whatever and we would have plenty of P0 spots"

P0 is not a fixed scarce number

good

but I think the idea of precommitting is also goo

you might miss out on something special at 3M

so that if you split your 3M into 1.5M each

it needs to be TDH based too

if we do surprises

full sets won't solve high TDH not full set splits

TDH is the only thing that matters but the only reason TDH is a good metric is because the whole system was designed to make TDH a good metric. AL is a tool to make TDH work

fine that is OK

so if someone says "sure I am truly genuinely trying to buy every card in SZN 15 x 3 and I have a lot of TDH sure"

in advance of knowing the winner

we allocate P0 for people who commit / subscribe to P0

I think that is tricky. how about this

where in principle if you are high enough in TDH to be able to get into P0 even if split in two, you can trade off neutral to lower TDH for more AL spots

now we need to address the question of high TDH non-full set

so with #1, if you have a full set your incentive is to consolidate because you get the same number of AL spots and more TDH

so i do not want to full myself/ourselves that we are doing things when they are trivially fakeable

you have just described (correctly) a trivial way a high TDH holder can take one of the spots for "new collector" by simply having another wallet

of course this is the reason but if we lock the front door but have the side door wide open then the reason is not going to be effective

imagine I have: 3 full sets, 1 in one wallet, 2 in another wallet and a third wallet with SZN-1 and SZN(current) TDH: I get 3 AL now in the new adjusted #1, I also get 3 AL and higher TDH

just the TDH split issue remains

made another small adjustment to 1d. with that adjustment, I think the set split issue goes away

but this is just deceiving ourselves

they just look like a "new collector" to us

fake news though. if an existing high TDH collector can get around it by having a second wallet, they are not a "new collector"

instead of 1

you get 2 ALs

forget full sets for a second

into 1.5M each

you split it