it is dropping systemwide
Shit Punk Says
Oceans of Wisdom
20,635
matching drops
#1553800
2026-10-20 16:15
it will drop whether you split them off or not
In regards to the larger TDH discussion around season set bonuses, I mean I think I prefer Punk's original proposal the best. Yes, the set bonus would drop for older seasons after you have held them 1 year, but the accumulated TDH on those would completely discourage splitting them off at that point. It seems like a nice way to incentivize new collectors and Old collectors to continue collecting new seasons, while having a cap.
but more than that, our future is here
i think it is now a vulnerability bc not being watched
i have not gone in months
Is there anything still happening on discord? I see no usecase
it makes it very clear what the problem is
just go design other AL mechanisms and try to hack them :)
i am admittedly not an anti-Sybil expert but I understand that is a key goal here
sure, but that in and of itself does not matter (novelty)
to understand this discussion, you should think carefully about why TDH is like this for every other case except this fringe edge case
I agree, TDH is potentially novel. it’s for sure a reason I’m here
it is just a convenient one to start with in the NFT space
it is a minor issue within a class of important issues
is not some minor issue
and "how to fairly allocate an allowlist spot"
is worse than TDH
except TDH
literally every AL allocation I have seen in the NFT space
and you then have no idea that actual nature of your society
to increase their chances
so of course you incent people to create sock puppet accounts
is what most people do
"lottery among all holders of cards"
"you have 300 valuable allowlist spots. how do you allocate them"
imagine it very simply as follows
it is the whole principle of TDH
in principle
well it is not fringe
this is the point of TDH
of course
even if small
the algorithm should be right in all cases
but still
and they mostly have not split (to their detriment)
bc very very few multiple set owners
again mostly theoretical issue
yes
yes
yes
This is for a person with 2 sets under one 6529 account
I want the incentives to get to the right outcome by themselves
I do not want to reply on good citizenship (though that is important)
i do not like leaving open holes in that structure
is to incent people to be consolidated
and the whole incentive structure of TDH itself
and since the whole concept here is to prevent sybil attacks
and if you leave them in one, you get 1 AL spot
bc you get 2 AL spots
you are better off having them in 2 wallets
right now for AL purposes
if you have 2 sets
it is very simple
I think my issue is I’m not able to form a concrete example in my head of an attack via the wallet splitting technique
IMPORTANT
I think we should shut down our discord (archive it). Discuss
presumably has to apply there too