Oceans of Wisdom

we launched it

we build it

so this is the benefit of my incrementalist approach

a superb idea as always ser

and it is not great for that audience

it starts to look like eigenlayer or something

if I then add into it indexers, oracles, incentives etc etc

I can explain in 5 sentences why it is 'safe'

and say "TDH is extremely robust on decentralization"

which is going to hard core OG crypto decentralization maxis

and I am thinking about an audience that almost none of you are thinking about

i am saying that this is another use case that is not covered by current implementation of xTDH

that TDH is extremely robust decentralized

because then you can have a cleaner story

lets' have TDH and xTDH and not add them up to TDH

when I said

this is what I was getting at a few weeks ago

so if that is the case, I should be able to allocate green bay packers xTDH

it is because you are inside the sausage making factory while the sausage is being made

and so I think we should allow the green bay packers to do this

by me

and at a very low cost

but of course my database is in fact privately indexable

but of course my database is not publicly indexable

I want to "xTDH them"

I have 200,000 fans

I am the Green Bay Packers

let me give you an example

pros 1/ yes you can expand network, etc etc 2/ also I think xTDH is probably not the final state, I think it is a subset of a bigger idea

they cannot socialize the cost on everyone else

the person ordering the lobster needs to pay for the lobster

you need to pay with ETH

if you want to put an absurdly inefficient transaction on ethereum

why should the whole network have to pay for your absurdly expensive xTDH allocation

pros

so this is the problematica part

they have to pay for that cost

so that obviously can't e the way

they are imposing a huge cost on someone

so at a tiny cost to the person

someone wants to allocate 1 xTDH total, split across every Solana holder

let me take an extreme example

for how long

who pays them

the con part is "how do you pay them"

1/ vastly expands the complexity of indexing (unbounded) 2/ means you can't force each node to do it because you then lose decentralization 3/ which means you then need specialized indexers 4/ they can consolidate their indexing into a provable form using ZKP and pass it into a transaction so far, so good, there are no problems in principle with the above

cons first

like let me give you the pros and cons

so I reserve my right to see how we like it centralized before making the final architectural approach

it is a pain in the ass